Dave Ramsey should cut it out

I like Dave Ramsey.  It was because of his book, Total Money Makeover, that I started using the envelope system, and actually now save some money each month.  I think he’s being proven correct right now about being debt-free – and I’m working to get there myself.

But he’s still telling people to put their money in “quality index funds” so you can earn “14% over time” – WHAT??  There is NO truth to the 14% number (actually that’s the highest I’ve ever seen – 10%, 12% is the usual number).  In this market, telling people to do this is a complete misrepresentation of what their specific, actual results may or may not be.

The simple fact is that any money put into index mutual funds 10 years ago are back where they were then.  There has been NO increase in the last ten eyars – let alone 14%!!  How many people will blindly do this based on his suggestion alone?

He is good with the “get out of debt” idea. But he should just plain stop telling people where to put their investment money.  The whole “stick it in an index fund and sit back and enjoy the winnings” method is out the window.  It never really was true, and today even less so, that this is the best way to invest.

Bottom line:  If you don’t know anything about investing, stay out of the market.  Don’t get your advice from people on tee vee.  If you want to hire somone, you better know what the heck they are talking about, or you’ll get screwed, either intentionally or accidentally.  If you don’t know and don’t want to know, then buy CDs.  Anyone who invested in a 6% CD ten years ago would right now be far far ahead of anyone who had their $$ in the market.

Related articles by Zemanta

• How I Paid Off $35,000 in Debt, and How You Can Too
• Crunch Time – Prepare For the Personal Credit Tsunami